top of page
Search

To Keep or Not to Keep: The Fate of Your Original VHS Tapes After Digitising

Digitising old VHS tapes has become a popular way to preserve memories and free up physical space. But once you have a digital copy, a common question arises: should you keep the original tapes or get rid of them? This post explores the emotional, practical, and preservation aspects of this decision. It aims to help you make an informed choice about storing, disposing of, or archiving your original VHS tapes without pushing any sales agenda.


Eye-level view of a shelf filled with original VHS tapes in their cases
Original VHS tapes neatly stored on a shelf

Emotional Value of Original VHS Tapes


For many, VHS tapes hold more than just video content. They carry memories of family events, childhood moments, or personal milestones. The physical tape can evoke nostalgia that a digital file cannot replicate. Holding the tape, seeing the handwritten labels, or even the smell of the plastic case can trigger strong emotions.


  • Sentimental attachment often makes it hard to part with original tapes.

  • Some people keep tapes as family heirlooms to pass down.

  • The tactile experience of handling tapes can feel more personal than clicking a file on a screen.


If you feel a strong emotional connection to your tapes, keeping at least some originals might be worth it. You can select the most meaningful ones to store safely while digitising the rest.


Practical Considerations for Keeping VHS Tapes


Storing original VHS tapes requires space and proper conditions. Tapes are bulky and can degrade over time if not stored correctly.


  • Storage space: VHS tapes take up much more room than digital files. If space is limited, keeping all tapes may not be practical.

  • Environmental factors: Heat, humidity, and magnetic fields can damage tapes. Ideal storage is a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight.

  • Accessibility: Digital files are easier to access and share. Tapes require a working VCR, which is becoming rare and expensive to maintain.


If you decide to keep tapes, organize them well and store them in protective cases. Label them clearly to avoid confusion later.


Preservation and Longevity of VHS Tapes vs Digital Copies


VHS tapes degrade physically over time. Magnetic tape can lose signal quality, become brittle, or suffer from mold and dust. Digitised files, if backed up properly, can last indefinitely without quality loss.


  • Tape lifespan: Typically 10 to 30 years depending on storage conditions.

  • Digital files: Can be copied endlessly without degradation.

  • File formats: Choose widely supported formats like MP4 for longevity.

  • Backup: Store digital copies on multiple devices or cloud services to prevent data loss.


Despite digitising, some experts recommend keeping original tapes as a backup in case digital files get corrupted or lost. However, this depends on your willingness to maintain physical storage.


When It Makes Sense to Dispose of Original Tapes


If you have limited space, no emotional attachment, and reliable digital backups, disposing of original tapes can be a reasonable choice.


  • Recycle tapes: Look for local recycling programs that accept VHS tapes to reduce environmental impact.

  • Donate: Some organizations or collectors may accept tapes for reuse or repurposing.

  • Dispose responsibly: Avoid throwing tapes in regular trash to prevent plastic waste.


Before disposal, double-check that your digital copies are complete and accessible. Losing original tapes without a backup can mean losing memories forever.


Tips for Long-Term Archiving of Digitised Content


Whether or not you keep original tapes, managing your digital archive is crucial.


  • Organize files: Use clear folder structures and consistent naming conventions.

  • Metadata: Add descriptions, dates, and tags to files for easy searching.

  • Multiple backups: Keep copies on external drives and cloud storage.

  • Regular checks: Periodically verify file integrity and update storage media as technology evolves.


Good digital archiving practices ensure your memories remain safe and accessible for years to come.


Balancing Emotion and Practicality


Deciding what to do with original VHS tapes after digitising is a personal choice. Consider these questions:


  • How much space do you have for physical storage?

  • Do you feel a strong emotional connection to the tapes?

  • Are your digital copies backed up and accessible?

  • Can you store tapes in conditions that prevent damage?


Some people keep a few special tapes and recycle or discard the rest. Others keep everything as a physical archive. Both choices are valid as long as they fit your needs and resources.


Ready to digitise your VHS tapes?

If you’re still unsure, our guide on different tape formats explains how VHS, VHS-C, Hi8 and MiniDV tapes differ and what that means for digitisation.


If you’re still deciding what to do with your original tapes, the first step is often simply getting them digitised safely. Once you have a digital copy, you can take your time deciding whether to keep, archive, or responsibly dispose of the originals — without the pressure of tapes continuing to degrade.


If you’d like advice or help digitising your VHS tapes, you’re welcome to get in touch. We’re always happy to discuss your collection and explain the options before you decide how to proceed.




 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page